Italy Fines Meta €805 Million Over Default Android Photo Gallery Access
Italy's data regulator fined Meta €805 million for reading 20 million Android users' photo libraries by default without explicit consent.

By Jin, Founder & Startups
, updated 4 min read
Italy's data protection authority, the Garante per la protezione dei dati personali, has fined Meta Platforms €805 million (about $887 million) after finding that the Facebook Android app accessed users' personal photo libraries without specific consent.
The penalty is the largest ever issued by the Italian watchdog against a technology company and represents roughly 0.47% of Meta's global annual revenue.
How the Android gallery feature worked
The investigation focused on a Facebook feature active since 2023 labelled "Get suggestions from your gallery while browsing Facebook". The tool scanned photos, videos, and embedded file metadata stored on Android handsets to surface suggested posts inside the app.
According to the Garante, the setting was enabled by default across an estimated 20 million Android users in Italy. When users installed or updated the app, Facebook presented a vague prompt asking to "enable other features" alongside a broad system storage permission, failing to inform users that the app would continuously read their private camera roll.
Bypassing the GDPR one-stop-shop in Ireland
Meta argued during proceedings that any cross-border European privacy inquiry should sit with Ireland's Data Protection Commission, Meta's lead regulator under the EU General Data Protection Regulation (GDPR).
The Italian authority rejected that argument by grounding its enforcement in Article 122 of the Italian Privacy Code, which transposes the EU ePrivacy Directive. Because ePrivacy rules governing terminal equipment access do not fall under the GDPR one-stop-shop mechanism, national regulators can investigate and fine companies directly when an app reads data stored on a citizen's handset.
The Garante noted that its ruling did not determine whether Meta used the scanned local photos to train AI models, which Meta denied, though regulators will review separate cloud-processing tools independently.
Compliance deadlines and Meta's response
The order gives Meta 60 days to turn off the gallery suggestion feature by default and implement a separate, explicit opt-in consent flow, including for users who previously granted blanket storage permissions. Meta must file initial compliance steps within 30 days and a final implementation report within 90 days.
Meta stated that it strongly disagrees with the decision, called the €805 million penalty disproportionate, and confirmed it intends to appeal in Italian courts.
Frequently Asked Questions
Why was Italy able to fine Meta directly instead of deferring to Ireland?
The Garante enforced Article 122 of the Italian Privacy Code under the EU ePrivacy Directive, which governs access to data stored on user devices and is outside the GDPR one-stop-shop system.
What must Meta change within 60 days?
Meta must disable the Facebook Android gallery suggestions feature by default and introduce a separate, explicit consent mechanism for all affected users in Italy.
Did the ruling cover AI training on user photos?
No. The Garante stated that this ruling addressed unauthorised device-gallery access and did not establish AI model training, while separate cloud-processing features remain under review.
Subscribe to the TechWhoKnows newsletter for regulatory rulings, privacy enforcement, and global tech policy updates.
Sources
- 1Garante per la protezione dei dati personaligaranteprivacy.it
- 2Deutsche Welle Report on Italy Meta Finedw.com