Google AI Overviews Cut Website Clicks by 40% in Randomised Trial
A randomised controlled trial found Google's AI Overviews reduce clicks to external websites by 40%, with searches ending without any outbound click rising from 54% to 73%.

By TechWhoKnows
4 min read
A randomised controlled trial has found that Google's AI Overviews reduce clicks to external websites by approximately 40%, providing the strongest evidence yet that AI-generated search summaries are diverting traffic from publishers.
Researchers Saharsh Agarwal and Ananya Sen gave US desktop Chrome users a browser extension that randomly assigned them to two groups: one saw Google search results with AI Overviews, while the other had Overviews hidden. Over two weeks in January and February 2026, the group seeing Overviews averaged 0.37 clicks to outside websites per search, compared to 0.62 for the control group, a 39.8% reduction.
Searches ending with no outbound click at all rose from 54% to 73% when AI Overviews were present. Clicks on ads did not change, suggesting Google is taking care not to cannibalise its own advertising revenue. Across all searches, the authors estimate the loss at roughly 18.5% of the organic clicks a site receives from Google.
The study, published as a working paper (not yet peer-reviewed), covers desktop searches only. A separate preregistered experiment by Wang and colleagues with 1,100 participants also found that removing AI Overviews and AI Mode increased clicks to publishers.
Observational data from DataForSEO supports the experimental findings. The desktop click-through rate of the first organic result fell from 17.83% in September 2025 to 7.43% in August 2026, a 58% drop. Mobile CTR fell from 25.17% to 20.80%, a 17% decline. Desktop CTR plunged nearly half in a single month (March 2026) and remained depressed.
AI Overviews now appear on 61.43% of the 20 million US keywords DataForSEO tracks monthly, up from 5.93% in September 2024. The rate exceeds 50% for every search intent category: informational (70.44%), commercial (51.35%), navigational (34.03%) and transactional (28.64%). Even low-volume keywords with 201, 300 monthly searches show Overviews 58.59% of the time.
The report also examines which sites AI Overviews cite. YouTube, Reddit, Facebook, Wikipedia and Google.com lead Google's citation rankings, while Wikipedia, Reddit, Fandom, Britannica and NIH lead ChatGPT's. Reddit and Wikipedia rank near the top of both platforms. However, 27.3% of ChatGPT answers cited no source at all, compared to just 0.7% for AI Overviews.
On the question of "generative engine optimisation" (GEO), the data suggests it largely resembles traditional SEO. Referring-domain counts correlate moderately with AI citations (Spearman 0.406 for AI Overviews, 0.377 for ChatGPT). Pages cited in Overviews often do not rank for the query in ordinary results, meaning citation and ranking are distinct surfaces.
Google disputes that search traffic to websites is declining. In August 2025, Google's head of Search Liz Reid wrote that total organic clicks were "relatively stable year-over-year" and that Google was sending "slightly more quality clicks", though no figures were provided to support the claim.
Sources
- 1RevScope analysis of randomised trialrevscope.co
- 2Hacker News discussionnews.ycombinator.com